Playing Hard to Get with a Girl: Mistakes Guys Make & How to Do It Right

You like this girl, but you don’t want to seem too overeager. So, how do you play hard to get with a girl? Don’t worry, we have all the answers you need.

play hard to get with a girl

There are many dating “things” that have existed since the beginning, well probably, of dating but what is the truth behind whether they work or do more harm than good? Should you play hard to get with a girl? Is that ethically right? And most importantly, are there times when you HAVE to do it?

Playing hard to get means so many things to so many people. The theory behind playing hard to get is that you try to convince someone that you are worthy of them waiting for you, that you can’t be bought, or that you can’t be taken advantage of.

The harder someone is to get, the theory holds, the more that you want them.

In terms of psychology, that would make sense. Those things that we can’t have are the very things that we often want more than anything. Why do we want them? Well, simply because we can’t have them! [Read: The art of getting your crush to notice you and like you back]

When it comes to girls and attracting them, however, does playing hard to get with a girl really work? If you are too eager, show a girl all the cards that you have too early, or follow them around obsessively, that is a huge turnoff, but so too is a guy who can’t seem to be bothered with girls.

[Read: Do guys play hard to get? The honest truth, 21 reasons and what girls do]

How should a guy play hard to get with a girl?

When it comes to playing hard to get, girls have somehow mastered this art. Almost all of them know this secret. And the secret is simple.

The secret to playing hard to get with a girl is about letting a girl know you like her by the way you behave around her. But without telling her or verbally confirming that in any way.

That’s it. If you can master this simple task of making your intentions clear with your behavior, but never confirming that in words, you’ll have her hooked. She’ll want to know what’s on your mind, and she’ll try harder to win your affections and get you to say that you like her.

Most guys either try to hurt the girl by being aloof, or go the other extreme and confess just how deeply they’re in love with her. And both these extremes end up killing the game of playing hard to get.

After all, if you show no interest in a girl, she’d think you don’t like her. And if you show too much interest in her, she knows she’s completely won you over and won’t care anymore because she doesn’t even have to consider the possibility of her trying to win your affection.

Playing hard to get with a girl: When you shouldn’t do it

There has to be some happy medium, but you are probably confused about where that is. The biggest reason you are confused is that it is different for every girl. 

If you want to play hard to get with a girl, you need to remember that girls are not only different from each other, they are different from year to year, day to day, and sometimes even minute to minute!

A tactic that may work one day will be a huge turn-off the next. As difficult as it may seem to do, you have to learn to listen to the signs that she is feeding you to know how to play hard to get with her. 

These are the top signs she is sending you and how to react to them, either by playing hard to get or quitting the games altogether. [Read: How to make a girl fall for you without ever asking her out]

1. She is extremely nervous around you

If she is showing signs of being nervous or insecure around you, that is a sign that she really likes you and probably thinks you may be out of her league. 

In situations where a girl is not very secure about herself or thinks that you may be out of her league, you don’t want to play hard to get.

If she senses that you aren’t into her, and she is a shy person, she will likely just decide not to play the game. If you don’t answer her, or ignore her, she will assume that you don’t like her and will not put forth the effort to take things any further.

With a shy girl, she isn’t not texting you because she is playing a game, she is likely lacking the confidence to make the first move. 

Don’t make the mistake to think that she is playing games, sitting on the sidelines isn’t going to get you anywhere with this type of girl. [Read: 18 foolproof ways to make a shy girl fall in love with you]

2. She acts like she can’t be bothered by you

If she is only giving you attention when she feels like it, then she is probably playing games with you. Girls only have two ways of dealing with things, if she likes you, she will engage, if she doesn’t, she will probably not even answer you.

With the kind of girl who is only halfway in, she probably is very secure in herself and is looking for a mate who will challenge her. If she is only answering you when it is convenient for her, then you have to fight fire with fire. 

If you are too eager, text too much, or come on too strong, she will feel like she has control over you and will probably not respect you enough to make you her long-term guy.

The best thing to do with this type of girl is to wait for her to make the first move, then don’t answer right away. Make her come to you. 

Never seem eager, or go the extra mile until you are sure that she will do the same for you. Equality is the key to winning over a girl who is confident, cares less, and knows what she wants. [Read: How to make a girl chase you – 20 secret ways to win her heart and mind]

3. She is really frustrated with you

If you are sensing anger from her, then you are probably doing the wrong thing. The last thing you want to do is to frustrate her. There are certain behaviors that some guys exhibit that bring out the crazy in girls. Don’t do that. 

Once you bring out the crazy eyes, they never go back in. A girl who feels as if she is being played, or being used, is going to react with aggression and anger.

If you play hard to get with a girl and push it too far by insulting her in some way, it is definitely the wrong road to go down and can start your relationship off on the wrong foot. 

If you notice that you are getting sarcastic messages from her, angry texts, or just downright mean replies, you are going overboard. It is time to back off and stop pretending like you don’t like her if you really do.

You want to get her to find you attractive, not repulsive. Making her feel frustrated and angry will eventually lead to dumpsville. [Read: How to woo a girl – 23 ways to sweep a woman off her feel and awe her]

4. She seems hurt by your behavior

Sometimes, guys think that playing hard to get means that you tell a girl you are going to do something, and then at the last minute, change your mind or flake and just don’t show up. That is not playing hard to get, that is being downright rude and insensitive.

If you want to play hard to get with a girl the right way, it should be about making her wait just a little longer for a text message, or holding back on telling her that you want her to be your future wife.

It is not about being an ass, blowing her off, or making her feel insecure or insignificant.

You aren’t in grade school anymore, hitting her in the arm, or hurting her feelings didn’t work back then, and it isn’t going to work now. It will just make her think you aren’t a very nice person. [Read: 28 heartfelt ways to apologize and say sorry to someone you like]

5. She is coming up with stupid excuses to avoid you

If you ask her to meet you or you ask her out, is she coming up with stupid excuses? It is time to stop and back away. There is a difference between playing hard to get and just letting things go. 

If you feel like she isn’t interested, pushing her further isn’t going to make her interested, it is going to make her want to avoid you altogether.

That old phrase about if you love something let it go, if it was meant to be, you will know, is true. If she is making up excuses not to be around you, then it isn’t really about playing hard to get, it is about truly making the decision to move on. 

You will know quickly whether she is interested. Once you stop calling, if she wants you, she will reach out to you. Don’t wait a week and think I should try again… you shouldn’t, ever. [Read: 27 clear signs she’s not interested in you anymore and wants you to back off]

6. She was really into you and now she is pulling away

Girls aren’t like guys. If they are pulling away, it is because there is something about you that she feels isn’t right, or she is losing attraction. The worst thing you can do at this point is to push her harder. 

If you feel her trying to cool things off, that is a situation when you should definitely “play hard to get.” The harder you push her, the more she will pull away.

If you aren’t getting much back, don’t reach out much. Go out with your friends or find other things to do and have the mentality that if she wants to join in, she will let you know. You have to put the seed out that you would like her to join, if she doesn’t catch the bait, go without her.

If she is on the fence, it isn’t as much about playing hard to get as it is about just taking a step back and giving her the space to figure out for herself what she wants out of the relationship. [Read: How to get a girl to like you again after she’s lost interest in you]

Girls usually walk away from games instead of playing it

Men make the mistake of thinking that girls want a guy to play games. We hate when we feel like we are being played with. There is definitely something attractive about a guy who is self-assured and doesn’t feel the need to cling, but by nature, we want to feel wanted.

If you show us that you aren’t interested, frustrate us, or smother us, then we are likely to move on.

Stop researching on how to play hard to get with a girl and try to listen to what she is telling you with her behavior.

There are signs all around you, just stop to take the time to discover not what women in general want, but what the woman you like wants, and your relationship will have a much higher likelihood of success.

The problem with playing hard to get with a girl is that once you start playing games, they are hard to stop and you don’t want to spend a relationship altering who you are, what you want, and the person you are.

If she needs space, give it to her, but have enough self-confidence to know that if she isn’t into you, someone else will be. [Read: 18 clear signs you’re already deep in a girl’s friend zone]

Showing her how great you are by continuing to be in her face just seems desperate. But being rude, negligent, or pretending that you don’t care for her is not the answer either.

Believe in yourself and she will see you as something worthy of her time and attention.

How to play hard to get with a girl the right way

Now that you know when you shouldn’t play hard to get with a girl, let’s talk about how you can do it the right way.

1. Play it cool when it comes to texting or calling to her

Even if you are extremely infatuated with her and can’t keep her off your mind, don’t be too eager when it comes to texting or calling her.

It’s one thing to let her know you like her, but it’s another thing to act desperate and needy.

And, if you text and call her too much, it might turn her off. Girls like guys with self-confidence. So, when you are too available to talk to her all the time, it sends the message that you don’t have a life. Or that you have already fallen hard for her. If she thinks that, you will become less attractive to her. [Read: How to play it cool with a girl and impress her by keeping your calm]

2. Let her initiate more than half of your interactions

Just because we suggested that you play it cool with your communication with her, that doesn’t mean that you can’t ever contact her. You need to let her know that you’re interested, but you also want her to wonder how much you’re interested. You want to leave a little mystery for her.

So, let her initiate at least half – if not more – of the texting or calling between the two of you. If you are the only one making the effort, then you might not know how she really feels.

But, if she is actively contacting you, then you know she is pretty interested. Otherwise, she wouldn’t do it. [Read: How to talk to a girl – The secrets to smoot talk and impress girls]

3. Don’t open up about your feelings

You might want to shout how you feel about her from the rooftops, but that is something you should hold back. If you don’t go overboard telling her how pretty she is or how lucky you are to be with her, then she will wonder how you feel.

You don’t have to hold back the feelings forever, but you do want her to have to work a little to get you to open up about them. Women like that kind of challenge for some reason, so let her do it.

4. Don’t be too available

This means not only being too available either over text or phone, but also in terms of hanging out. If you text her back within seconds of her text, she’ll think all you do is wait around to see if a text from her comes in.

Instead, wait a little while so you don’t seem overeager. [Read: How to make a girl think about you – 22 ways to be on her mind]

If she suggests hanging out, don’t say that you can do it “anytime.” Again, that shows that you have no life other than waiting around to see her.

You need to let her know that you have a life outside of her. Your schedule is busy with friends, work, and other priorities. So, don’t just jump at any and every chance to see her.

5. Always be polite

Just because you are playing hard to get with a girl, that doesn’t mean you have to be rude. In fact, you shouldn’t be rude. You should always be friendly and polite.

If you are rude to her, then she will be turned off and your “hard to get” game will push her away.

So, be always be kind, and always be polite to her, whether you’re texting or seeing her face to face. [Read: How to be charming – 15 adorable habits of really likeable people]

6. Make her wait for sex

This seems like something that girls do to guys, doesn’t it? Well, that doesn’t mean guys can’t play that game with a girl too. It’s not usually something that women expect from men, so it will make her wonder.

Not only will it make her wonder, but it will also build sexual tension between the two of you. She will think you are a gentleman, but she will also be dying to rip your clothes off. So, when the time comes to have sex, it will be very hot.

7. Make her miss you

As the saying goes, “absence makes the heart grow fonder.” So, by using all of these strategies we just discussed, it will make her miss you. That’s what you want. When she misses you, she will be even more excited when she does see you.

[Read: How to impress a girl – The atypical advice you really need]

Playing games to control each other sounds like fun. But in the long run, you’re not progressing nor are either of you feeling secure or loved. You can go ahead and play hard to get with a girl, but really, where do you see that going?

Liked what you just read? Follow us on Instagram Facebook Twitter Pinterest and we promise, we’ll be your lucky charm to a beautiful love life.

LovePanky icon
Team LovePanky
The editorial team of LovePanky comprises relationship experts and real-life experts that share their experiences and life lessons. If you want the best love ad...